Cat eyeliner-lovin’ cat ladies cannot line on gels and pencils alone. The cosmetics-loving cat enthusiast community is completely united on this point.
It simply can’t be done. I, for one, have liquid liner coursing through my veins. That’s how much I love the stuff.
The last liquid liner I had a lecherous liaison with with was Tom Ford’s flawless Eye Defining Pen in Deeper, but good grief, Charlie Brown! — that $55 price tag is totally insane.
Since then, I’ve had my sights set on more affordable liquid liners…
I wondered if Jane’s $8 Water-Resistant Liquid Eye Liners were worth their drugstore price, and well — for $8, it’s pretty hard to go wrong. Perfect, they’re not, but they are available in a wide range of colors (13, to be exact); have a high-gloss, waterproof finish; and you can get a similarly shiny look to MAC’s $19.50 Superslicks Liquid Liners if you don’t mind putting in a little work.
What do I mean?
Two words: the brush.
I don’t know what it is with me and thin, flexible brushes, but we just don’t get along. And these are like Olympic gymnasts (read: very flexible), so drawing really sharp edges, like at the wing, is no easy feat. With these I definitely have to (or at least should) run a Q-tip dipped in makeup remover along the edges to clean up any mistakes.
If you’re an experienced liquid liner wearer, you’ll probably be fine, but beginners might need some time to really get the hang of it.
Even considering the brush, though, I do think these have major potential, and I’d even go so far as to call them respectable dupes for the MAC Superslicks.
Sure, I find myself needing several layers of Jane’s liners (as opposed to just one or two of MAC’s) to achieve that signature Superslick look, so that’s also something to consider. That, and I have to remember to keep my hands off my eyes when I wear them, because any rubbing at all and they flake, flake, flake.
I’ve tried three of the 13 colors so far (a dark metallic navy blue, a metallic purple and a pale pink with silver glitter), and I’m partial to the darker colors. Seems like I don’t have to layer them as much to get a good amount of color.
From this batch, Metallic Lilac — a straight-up jewel-toned purple that isn’t overly red — is my fave, and I bet it’s going to look great on just about every eye color. Browns, greens, blues, hazels — you name it.
PRICE: $8 each (available in 13 shades)
AVAILABILITY: Available now online and at drugstores
MAKEUP AND BEAUTY BLOG RATING: B
Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,
Karen
Whenever I’m in Ulta, I browse through the Jane rack, but I’ve never taken the plunge. Thanks for doing it for me! I love the colors of those liners: the lilac is lovely, and for me, I would love that Bleu Marine with my blue-grey eyes. But I really appreciate the review because I have a problem with super flexible liquid liner brushes. I don’t think I’d be able to get it on there well enough, boo hoo. But I just saved $8, tyvm
This is gorgeous on you, but the brush might be more effort than I’m willing to put in most days, LOL. I love liquid liners and find them easier than pencil liners most of the time (unless I have a really good pencil liner), but those long, skinny brushes are a pain.
I need to pick up some more liquid liner, note to self.
That blue looks really pretty! I might have to go look for these at my local drugstore.
I like liquid liners over pencil ones and bleu marine looks great!
The liners are pretty but I loved blue one the most..will check that out!! 🙂
The colors are lovely but I hate the brush. It’s a nightmare to apply liners with such ultra thin flexible brushes.
I love the metallic pink.
Bleu Marine is beautiful! My favorite of the three!
That purple is gorgeous, and I need it NOW! I always look at the Jane display when I’m in ulta, but I haven’t taken the plunge with the new line. I loved the old Jane stuff back in the day! (I sound old there don’t I? lol)